Reddit does not settle whether cold email still works. The threads below were opened on 16 November 2026. Each figure is a number that poster or commenter wrote about their own sending. It is not a twl result, and it is not a rate this site measured.

People searching cold email reddit, reddit cold email, cold email strategy reddit, cold email outreach reddit, best cold email reddit or does cold email still work reddit get arguments, tool pitches and personal logs. A set of r/coldemail links did not open: Reddit showed that community as banned. Those threads are not cited. Where a comment is summarised, it is a comment on the thread linked in that section.

Does cold email still work#

On r/SaaS, a poster asked whether cold email still works in 2025. The post lists the split this page keeps meeting: some people say filters, domains and a full inbox have finished the channel, and others say a smaller list still gets replies.

The comments go the same way. One commenter wrote that everything still works, and that the useful question is how well it works and whether it is worth the time. Another said separate, warmed domains and smaller campaigns, and less spray-and-pray. A founder who also runs a design agency wrote that outreach usually dies when the list is scattered or the domain is burned, and that smaller batches to people they had a reason to contact brought replies back. One commenter said it is dead. Another said it never worked. A further commenter said they still send, with a curated list and lower volume, and named Lemlist as the sequencer they use. lemlist vs twl reach is this site’s comparison of that kind of engagement platform. It is not an endorsement of the comment.

A different r/SaaS post reports 592,318 cold emails, 13,696 replies, a 2.3% reply rate, 2,590 high-intent leads and 881 meetings booked. Those are the original poster’s figures for “the last year-ish” of their own campaigns. The same post says more volume does not fix a bad list. Several commenters called the post an advertisement and asked for cost and return, which the post does not give. One commenter said the data is worth having only if it is true. Read the 2.3% as that poster’s self-report, with that argument sitting under it.

The poster also named Instantly for sending accounts, warm-up and campaigns. Instantly vs twl is the comparison on this site. It does not confirm that poster’s experience.

If you want the arithmetic on a reply rate you choose yourself, the reply-rate calculator multiplies assumptions you can edit. The defaults are labelled as assumptions. They are not these Reddit figures.

Deliverability and why cold emails go to spam#

A r/sales post on why outreach goes to spam says inbox providers look for patterns: the same email to many people in a short time, bulk mail with links, images or attachments, and mail to people who never reply while the sending address is new. The poster says a primary domain is the wrong place for that pattern, because a spam placement hits the domain’s reputation. Their setup is a lookalike domain, inboxes in a person’s name rather than info@ or sales@, and plain text.

They prefer Google Workspace, keep three inboxes on a domain (they have seen others use four), and name .com, .org and .info as the endings they stick to, with .ai and .co “alright” in their experience. They tell the reader to verify addresses, and they warn against open tracking. Their reason is the tracking pixel: a hidden image that some clients surface with a prompt to report the message as spam.

A second r/sales post, from someone who makes cold-email software, describes their own Google audit of that software. They argue for a visible unsubscribe link. They say spam reports then tend to unsubscribe the person, and that inbox placement doubled in many of their cases, while the reply rate fell. They also published a worked example of 1,000 emails and labelled those percentages as mostly example values. This page does not repeat that example as a campaign result.

The same poster says formatting should look like ordinary mail: plain text, bold and italic, one or two links, and lists. They list colours, images, banners, GIFs and headings as things they removed. An older r/sales deliverability checklist makes related points: an unsubscribe path, SPF and DKIM, no attachment on the first email, and caution with short URLs and heavy HTML. The highest-scored reply on that checklist is two words: call them. A deliverability commenter under it goes further than the list and says to skip links if you can, ask for a reply, send plain text, and customise with something other than a first name, such as industry, location or a relevant date.

The deliverability checklist on this site is a list you tick in the browser. Ticking it does not test placement. The spam checker highlights words that often show up in bulk mail. It does not predict the inbox.

How many cold emails per day per inbox#

The daily numbers in these threads are personal caps.

The r/sales spam post above calls more than 50 people a day volume, and then tells the reader to stay at 10 to 15 emails per inbox per day, with a few minutes between sends when the copy is the same. The software poster on r/sales writes that Google still allows 1,500 emails a day, which they describe as one a minute, and says a sender should stay far under that. Their own pace is a 3 to 5 minute gap, which they calculate as 288 emails a day, 10 minutes for a newer address (their figure: 144 a day), and a cap of 50 a day on a long-running campaign. They say they would treat those caps as per domain even if the allowance is per user. They also write that domains used only for warm-up and bulk sending landed in spam about five times as often in their audit, and that the practical cap on those domains was often under 20% of the main domain, which they put at 25 to 50 emails a day.

The 2018 checklist says to start around 40 to 50 emails and to keep the daily volume steady, because 100 emails in a minute looks like bulk mail. On the warm-up thread in the next section, one commenter says 20 to 30 a day is a different problem from 200 a day. Two hundred a day, in that comment, is a reason to add mailboxes, not a reason to stretch one mailbox.

An r/saasbuild poster, in the LinkedIn section below, reports 200 to 300 emails a day per rep. That is their team’s volume, not a ceiling anyone else in these threads adopted.

Warm-up#

An r/Coldemailing post on how long to warm a mailbox says the clock depends on the domain. The poster’s ranges: four to six weeks for a new domain and a new mailbox, starting at 5 to 10 emails a day; two to three weeks when the domain is already established and only the mailbox is new; sometimes faster on an aged domain with a clean history. A domain that only looks old because it was burned before, they write, is worse than starting fresh. They say warm-up mail sent through random relays, rather than real Google Workspace or Microsoft 365 mailboxes, can run for eight weeks and still produce no reputation lift. The stop condition they give is a clean inbox-placement check for a few days, not a date on a calendar.

Comments on that thread do not collapse to one length. One says warm-up is not a phase you exit, and that jumping from 20 a day to 200 undoes it. Warming toward 20 to 30 a day, that commenter writes, is a couple of weeks. Other commenters say 14 days, 21 days, two to three weeks, or three weeks if the warm-up was done properly.

The r/sales spam guide is shorter: run warm-up for two weeks before any outreach, then send fewer warm-up emails once real outreach starts. The 2018 checklist’s version is a small daily volume, around 40 to 50 emails, while reputation builds, sent every day rather than in spikes.

twl does not warm inboxes. The warm-up schedule only writes a day-by-day plan from numbers you type, and it does not claim that following the sheet will build a reputation.

What templates and frameworks get replies#

The threads that opened do not crown a best cold email reddit template. They describe a shape.

On r/b2bmarketing, a post asks whether email or LinkedIn books more calls. One commenter said long LinkedIn introductions were ignored, and that a short line about a trigger worked better for them: a hire, or a funding round, followed by a short question. Another commenter on the same thread described “intent” as a reference to something the person said or wrote, such as a post, a podcast or an article, tied to the reason for writing. A third said cold email can book more calls at scale when the targeting is tight, and that LinkedIn replies are often higher and harder to turn into a meeting until there is some rapport.

On r/sales, a founder asked whether to use email or LinkedIn. One reply says to use LinkedIn to learn about the person before the email or the call, so the note is a dialogue. Another says their templates are industry-specific and should lead with a current, relevant fact about that company, then who they help, then a request for a time. The more current the fact, that commenter writes, the better the response has been for them.

Put next to the deliverability posts, the copy advice that repeats is plain text, no image, no tracking pixel, and one specific reason for this person. The sequence template fills a fixed structure with notes you type. No model writes it, and the page does not know whether anyone will reply. Edit it before it is a message to a named person.

Follow-ups#

These threads do not share a follow-up count or a gap in days.

The r/sales spam guide says follow-ups are acceptable for now, and that the better moment is after the person has replied. On r/b2bmarketing, one commenter says email is the easier place to run a series of follow-ups, and that LinkedIn’s messaging limits make a long drip harder. Their figures for those limits are their own estimate, covered in the next section. Another commenter on that thread starts with a LinkedIn touch and follows by email to ask for a time.

On r/saasbuild, a commenter argues that the waste is not using both channels. It is sending a follow-up on one channel after the person has already answered on the other, because the two tools do not share a reply. That is a comment about process. It is not a measured reply-rate test.

The follow-up cadence calculator dates the gaps you enter. It does not recommend a spacing or a reply rate. r/coldemail threads that argue for a specific number of follow-ups did not load, so this page does not import a number from them.

Cold email vs LinkedIn#

An r/saasbuild post compares the two channels from one team’s split. The poster says they are about 60/40 toward email, that a rep can send 200 to 300 emails a day against maybe 50 to 100 LinkedIn messages, and that their response rates are about 8 to 10% on LinkedIn and 2 to 3% on email. A commenter did the arithmetic on the middle of those ranges: about 250 emails at 2.5% is about six replies, and about 75 LinkedIn messages at 9% is about seven. Their point is to compare qualified conversations per hour, including follow-ups, before dropping a channel. Another commenter on the same thread says a 2 to 3% email reply rate is often a targeting problem, and that LinkedIn can be the first touch (view, engage, connect) with the email sent to the same person afterwards.

r/b2bmarketing is the same split, without a shared winner. Commenters say email reaches more people, LinkedIn conversations feel warmer, and some do both. One commenter, writing about their clients, claims 8 to 15% responses on targeted LinkedIn messages and 2 to 5% on cold email, and estimates a cap of maybe 100 to 200 personalised LinkedIn messages a week before an account is flagged. That cap is their estimate. LinkedIn does not publish one weekly invitation number. The LinkedIn limits guide separates the help-centre rules from figures that are only commonly reported.

On the older r/sales thread, one commenter wrote: “For every 1-2 meetings I book on LinkedIn, I booked 10 via cold email.” That is their book of meetings, and the same comment points at stacking domains. Another commenter prefers email first, then a LinkedIn connection when the email is not read, and reports that about 40 to 50% of those requests are accepted. A third says LinkedIn messages have a higher reply rate and that the practical answer is both channels. None of these comments shows the list, the offer or the time spent.

Where twl fits#

twl reach runs email and LinkedIn as one sequence, written from the signal that found the person. You review what sends. twl reach stays inside the account limits you set. It is not a way around LinkedIn’s limits. twl does not warm inboxes, and it does not publish a reply rate for this page to quote.

That is a narrower product than the stacks in these threads. The Reddit posts are about domains, daily caps, plain-text copy and a reason to write. twl reach is the sequence after that reason exists: the same person can be emailed and contacted on LinkedIn from the signal that put them in the queue. The outreach page is the product description. Prices stay on the pricing page.

Threads read on 16 November 2026#

Frequently asked questions#

Does cold email still work on Reddit?#

The threads opened on 16 November 2026 do not agree. Some r/SaaS commenters said it still works with a small list, a separate domain and a specific note. One said it is dead and not worth the time. Another said it never worked. A self-reported 2.3% reply rate on that subreddit drew comments calling the post an advertisement.

What reply rate do Reddit posters report?#

One r/SaaS poster reported 592,318 emails, 13,696 replies, a 2.3% reply rate and 881 meetings. The post gives no cost, and several commenters called it an ad. An r/saasbuild poster reported about 2 to 3% on email and 8 to 10% on LinkedIn for their team. One r/b2bmarketing commenter claimed 2 to 5% and 8 to 15% for their clients.

How many cold emails per inbox do Reddit posters send?#

The caps are personal. One r/sales poster stays at 10 to 15 emails per inbox per day. Another suggests 50 a day on long campaigns, under a 1,500-a-day figure they attribute to Google. A 2018 checklist starts near 40 to 50. A warm-up comment treats 20 to 30 a day as unlike 200 on one mailbox.

How long do Reddit posters warm a mailbox?#

No single length appears. One r/sales poster warms for two weeks. An r/Coldemailing poster says four to six weeks for a new domain, starting at 5 to 10 a day, and two to three weeks if the domain already exists. Others said 14 days, 21 days or three weeks. One said jumping from 20 a day to 200 undoes it.

Is LinkedIn better than cold email on Reddit?#

The posts split. One team reported a higher LinkedIn response rate and much more email volume. A commenter showed those rates can produce a similar number of replies. One r/sales commenter said they book many more meetings by email. Others research on LinkedIn and then write. LinkedIn publishes no single weekly invitation number.

twl Signals

Turn market attention into a qualified prospect feed.

Monitor the people and companies your buyers already follow, keep the original context, enrich the profiles and route only the strongest matches into outreach.

Start free trial